Our analysis on the nominees (16 categories) of the first European Animation Emile Awards.
Peter Lord (Aardman), and president of European Animation Awards announced (6 November 2017, Nexus Studio, UK) was the one to announce (along with EAA board members), all nominees for the first Emile Awards.
Emile Awards is a pan-European initiative (40 European countries) to get together all animation professionals in Europe, and have them voted by their peers -in a celebration of the diversity and excellence of European animation.
In overall, selection juries catered for both festival selections (awarded festival films are nominated here), and some audience favorites. It helps that there are more categories than one in the short and feature film competition -but short categories would definitely need to expand.
Best short film:
Among the black waves (Sredi chernyh voln) by Ana Budanova (Russia), The Burden (Min Börda) by Niki Lindroth von Bahr (Sweden), Chulyen, a crow’s tale (Chulyen, histoire de corbeau) by Cerise Lopez & Agnès Patron (France).
The eligibility rules of Emile Awards require previous screenings/awards in selected animation festivals. The three films that made the final nominees' cut go from the sad to menacing to the more weird.
The Annecy Cristal winner musical The Burden is getting one of the coveted place; the criminally underappreciated, 20-minute Chulyen, a crow's tale gets (almost mystically) a place among the nominees, whereas the awarded (and beautiful) short Among the Black waves completes the list.
Names and directors who could have been among the nominees (pre-selected but not in the final list): Nighthawk by Špela Čadež, Nothing Matters by Uri and Michelle Kranot, Johnno's Dead by Chris Shepherd, Three Fitted Flies by Elisa Morais and Maria Alvarez, Dead Horses by Marc Riba and Anna Solanas.
Best background and character design:
Peripheria by David Coquard-Dassault (France), Manivald by Chintis Lundgren (Estonia / Croatia), Rêve d'enfant (Child Dream), Christophe Gérard (France)
A comedy at last finds its place here: Chintis Lundgren's comedy of manners Manivald is nominated in this new category of character design and background; her orange /pink palette has to fight against the dark grays and purples of Peripheria. Christophe Gérard in his Rêve d'enfant presents an equally engaging portrait of a boy and his surroundings.
Best Student Film:
About a Mother (Pro Mamu) by Dana Velikovskaya (Russia), Merlot by Marta Gennari & Giulia Martinelli (Italy), O Mother! (O! Matko) by Paulina Ziolkowska (Poland)
Another deviant comedy, Merlot (M. Gennari and G. Martinnelli) finds a fine place in the set. The Polish film O Mother! also has a humorous, 2D eye on the eternal mother-son relationships, and competes with another black-and-white film on motherhood, About a Mother.
Films which could have been there: Sog by Jonatan Schwenk, How Are You Today? by Sophie Markatatos, Garden Party by Illogic
Jury (Short films): Carolina Lopez, Director of Animac (Spain), Alexis Hunot, Animation Activist (France), Regina Pessoa, Portuguese Independent Animation Director (Portugal).
- The Story of an Idea The Story of an Idea
- Among the Black Waves Among the Black Waves
- Chulyen Chulyen
- About a mother About a mother
- Oh, Mother! Oh, Mother!
- Merlot Merlot
- Otto 'Time' Otto 'Time'
- Peripheria Peripheria
- Manivald Manivald
- Child's Dream Child's Dream
- The Last Job on Earth The Last Job on Earth
- The Burden The Burden
In feature animation competition (6 categories overall), the surprise nominee was Le Grand méchant renard et autres contes (The big bad fox and other tales) by Benjamin Renner (director of Ernest and Celestine) & Patrick Imbert (France / Belgium). The film is based on B. Renner's own graphic novel, and premiered at the 2017 Annecy festival as a screening event; the film has no other nominations in the feature category.
The other two nominees, The Red Turtle (Michael Dudok de Wit) and My Life as a Zucchini (Claude Barras) is a worthy -and a rather expected set, considering their previous Oscar nominations.
J. F. Laguionie was shut out from the Best Feature competition; he was only nominated for Best Writing for the magnificent Louise en Hiver (Louise by the Shore). Similarly, the 2018 Oscar contender Psychonautas: The Forgotten Children (P. Rivero - A. Vazquez) grabbed two nominations (best background and character design - best storyboard), but failed to be nominated in either writing or best feature categories.
On the contrary, both the Raymond Briggs animated biography of his parents, Ethel and Ernest (Roger Mainwood), and Sacrebleu Productions Longway North (Rémi Chayé, France/ Denmark), each got 3 nominations. The Sebastien Laudenbach 2D feature tale of Brother Grimm's The Girl without hands (La jeune fille sans mains, France) was also nominated in the character animation and soundtrack feature animation categories.
Notable absent: Loving Vincent, D. Kobiela and H. Welchman
Since the final results are voted by all European Animation Awards members -being the first year of the awards as well- results are as unpredictable as they can be. But, judging from the number of nominations (no feature animation has a clear lead over the others), it would be safer to assume that there will be a split in the final voting as well.
- Ethel and Ernest Ethel and Ernest
- Psychonautas: The Forgotten Children Psychonautas: The Forgotten Children
- Longway North Longway North
- Louise en hiver Louise en hiver
- The Red Turtle The Red Turtle
- The big bad fox and other tales The big bad fox and other tales
- La jeune fille sans mains La jeune fille sans mains
A breakdown of nominations by film in Feature Animation:
La Tortue Rouge: Best feature (director), Best character animation, Best Storyboard
Psyconautas: Best background and character design, Best Storyboard
Tout en haut du monde: Best background and character design, Best Storyboard, Best Soundtrack
Ethel and Ernest: Best background and character design, Best character animation, Best Writing
Le jeune fille sans mains: Best character animation, Best Soundtrack
Le Grand méchant renard et autres contes: Best Feature (director)
Ma vie de courgette: Best feature (director), Best writing, Best Soundtrack
Louise en hiver: Best writing
Jury (feature films): Maria Anestopoulou, Festival Director/ Animasyros International Animation Festival & Agora (Greece), Tomm Moore, Director – Cartoon Saloon (Ireland), Claire Jennings, Independent Film Producer/Executive Producer (United Kingdom)
Cartoon Network's The Amazing World of Gumball leads with 4 nominations in the TV/Broadcast categories, but Revolting Rhymes by Jakob Schuh & Jan Lachauer follows closely with 3 nominations in a field where UK productions predominate. One example: all nominees for Best TV/Broadband productions are UK films.
Old friends like Cartoon Saloon's Puffin Rock or Ernest and Celestine TV series are also nominated (best background and character design).
Jury (TV/Broadcast Productions and Commissioned Films): Marion Edwards, Children’s Media Consultant (United Kingdom), Olivier Barbeau, Creative Director at Moka Studio (Switzerland), Yulia Aronova (Russia)
Jury (Soundtrack): Bruno Coulais, Composer (France), Emmanuel Deletang, CEO at 22D Music (France), Tom Van Waveren, Creative Director at Cake (Netherlands).
Veteran animator, filmmaker and 3-time Oscar winner Richard Williams deservedly got the Lotte Reiniger award for his achievement in animation, both professionally and academically.
Check all the Emile Awards nominees. Voting is open to all EAA members until 30 November 2017.
The first edition of the European Animation Awards will take place on Friday, December 8, 2017, at Le Nouveau Siècle in Lille, France. The award ceremony begins at 6:30p.m.